Quote from: KWKloeber on April 25, 2022, 11:32:07 PM[edited]
I didn't say or mean to imply failsafe behavior. I said failsafe reminder (like Noah's -- one cannot start the engine w/o receiving the reminder (some hang the engine key on the thru-hull handle.))
If one thereafter chooses to ignore the reminder (human behavior) so be it!
I often say you can lead (power)boaters to water but you can't make 'em think LOL! (tongue-in-cheek -- I'm also a PB.)
If one opens a thru hull ONLY when using the head or macerator I'd suspect that there's some reminder system that would always "tell" the user to IMMEDIATELY close it. What that might be of course depends on what works best for the individual and I wouldn't even try to conclude that I'd know what method works for someone else -- only what works for me.
But the head intake can also flood the boat. Kinda likewise, a stuck vent on the cooling seawater vented loop can back-flood the engine cylinders and ruin one's day -- and I know a chap who installed a solenoid valve that shuts off that hose unless the engine is running -- and another who installed a solenoid valve that drains the muffler unless the engine is running. And of course any thru hull that's left open (hoses will NEVER fail when one's aboard -- only when no one is on the boat.) I generally close 'em all (my reminder that the sink TH is closed is to put a stopper in the drain.)
[edit]
The manual:
7. Close valve "B" immediately after emptying the holding tank.
You're right that should carry the same warning as for the head intake valve!
THIS WILL PREVENT WATER FROM FLOODING THE BOAT BECAUSE SEAWATER CAN BACKFLOW THRU THE VALVE, FILL THE HOLDING TANK, AND THEN CAN FILL TOILET AND WILL OVERFLOW THE BOWL.