I replaced the dodger 5 seasons ago, was told that Strataglas was the preferred, and more expensive, material. It has held up well and is still as clear as new, but it does have some scratches. I've been on boats with the stiff polycarbonate. It is nice but is very stiff and more difficult to handle. I was told it's very hard to sew. I will consider it if I ever need to replace the Strataglas on the windshield over the cutouts for the lines.
I think you need to evaluate the canvas on the dodger. If it's very good, that is several seasons left, Strataglas or the polycarbonate, if it's worn, only a couple of seasons left, go with the less expensive.
That's my 2cents,
Jim
Another thought, On hot days it's nice to open up the center window and enjoy the breeze. You may want to consider adding that to canvas fix.
I think you need to evaluate the canvas on the dodger. If it's very good, that is several seasons left, Strataglas or the polycarbonate, if it's worn, only a couple of seasons left, go with the less expensive.
That's my 2cents,
Jim
Another thought, On hot days it's nice to open up the center window and enjoy the breeze. You may want to consider adding that to canvas fix.