Catalina 34

General Activities => Main Message Board => Topic started by: sdaly66 on May 25, 2007, 07:24:58 AM

Title: Shore power voltage & Tripped Breaker w/ Hot Water & A/C
Post by: sdaly66 on May 25, 2007, 07:24:58 AM
87' MK I

Staying one night at Baltimore Harbor Marina this weekend.  They're asking me what kind of shore power I need.

My first response was to reply "AC", but I didn't watn to tick them off.  LOL

So can anyone tell me what amperage I need.  50? 100? something else?

I can't find anything in prior posts or in the manual.  I can see that there's a 30 amp breaker in line, does that mean 30 is my max?

Never thought about this before.  Hooked up at my home marina has never been a problem.
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Stu Jackson on May 25, 2007, 07:31:48 AM
30 amps, thirty, 30 it is!

Page 32 of 66 (PDF page) of the manual: http://www.c34.org/manuals/1988/1988-C34-Owners.pdf

You're right, the breaker size is the "giveaway" as is the plug prong configuration.
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: sdaly66 on May 25, 2007, 07:45:39 AM
Thanks Stu, you're a lifesaver
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Stu Jackson on May 25, 2007, 07:50:32 AM
I forgot to note that usually the dock service determines what you get and there are 20, 30 and 50 A service usually available.  You can use adapters at the dock end of your own power cord.  You could get away with a 20A dock service if you don't have air conditioning.  It's rare that the full 30A is ever used - even when plugged in, do you run the HW heater with ALL the light and every receptacle being used?  Some boats with air conditioning have (2) 30 A boat plugs or have upped their single point service to a 50A.  I don't know what YOUR boat has. If you get a dock with 50A service you're fine, too, except for needing the adapter.

So, for grins & giggles, AC could mean air conditioning, too!   :D
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: sdaly66 on May 25, 2007, 07:58:54 AM
Gotcha.  No A/C (air conditioning) on board, and we're pretty frugal with the electricity in general.  Having spent the past few years with a C 250, one learns to be REALLY frugal.

Thanks again for the info.  Looking forward to a night on the town, and i know the admiral is gonna enjoy the health club at the hotel that they partner with.
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Footloose on May 25, 2007, 09:17:38 AM
The marina needed to know so that you are at a slip with the proper size receptacle.  The twist lock plug are different sizes for 20, 30 and 50 amps.  I have been at a transient slip with a 50 amp outlet.  It is a no go situation.  If you use an adaptor like Stu talks about you will be protected by you breaker if you are at a 50 amp station.  Without ac you could turn everthing on and probally not exceed 20 amps.
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: sdaly66 on May 25, 2007, 09:40:33 AM
I am once again, amazed and grateful at the speed and helpfulness of the folks here.

Thank you all.
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Stu Jackson on May 25, 2007, 10:49:26 AM
Dave's right IF you don't have an adapter ("I have been at a transient slip with a 50 amp outlet.  It is a no go situation. ")

Some harbors provide you with one (for a refundable fee).  For instance, Pillar Point Harbor, 18 miles down the coast from San Francisco, has lots of 50 A boxes at their docks, since it's a working fishing fleet harbor.  The harbor master can provide you with a pigtail adapter from the shore end of your 30 A power line to the 50 A plug at the dock box.  They stick it on your credit card for $100 and return it when you return the pigtail.

I've considered making up my own from Home Depot materials, just haven't gotten around to it.
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Footloose on May 25, 2007, 12:23:14 PM
Stu,

I have also thought about making my own adapter but the parts are way more expensive than you might think.  I would probally buy a pre-made pigtail if I were to go for this.  The last time I priced a 50 amp male twist lock plug and a 30 amp female twist lock it came to about $50. :cry4`
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Stu Jackson on May 25, 2007, 12:35:11 PM
Dave, that's a bargain.  The Marinco 121A 50A male to 30A female is $150 before tax.
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Ron Hill on May 26, 2007, 06:59:43 PM
sadly :  Anytime you need more than a single 30amp service you have more than the factory put on the boat!! 
If you screw around with 50 amp (220v) you had better have an adapter to only take the current off of 2 pins for 110v!!   :wink:
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Stu Jackson on May 29, 2007, 12:43:28 PM
The Marinco (Model 6152SPP-25, 25 foot, they make 50 footers, too) 50A PowerCord PlusĀ® Cordset - 50A, 125/250V is indeed both voltages.  Please note that if properly wired (at both ends), plugging into a 50A outlet in the United States will still get you 120V AC.  We used an adapter as noted in a previous post, with no trouble.  If you check a basic AC wiring book, you'll see that the different voltages are for different taps off the four wires available in this cordset.
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Bob K on May 29, 2007, 06:57:48 PM
Here's something you might find interesting.....I made the mistake last year of turning on the hot water heater while the air conditioning was on.  The breaker did not blow, as I would have expected it to if overloaded.  Rather, it functioned fine for a day or so while plugged in at a marina, and then melted mid-afternoon the next day.  The stink was a dead give-away.  Luckily we were on board, as we were waiting out a spell of bad weather.  After turning off all power and unplugging from shore power, I could feel the panel was very hot at the main 30A breaker. A secondary 30A main breaker located closer to the AC plug (in the lazerette) was running cool.  So I guess the panel breaker had a defect (?), started to heat up, and went into thermal runaway.  So I replaced the breaker, and no longer try to "see what she will do"!   If I turn on the hot water, I give the A/C a rest.    I don't think the combined amperage was over 25A, but obviously the breaker could not handle it.  So I now make it a point to feel the panel every now and then to make sure it is cool ragardless of what I have running.   
Title: Re: urgent shore power question
Post by: Stu Jackson on May 29, 2007, 08:42:29 PM
That's a good idea, Bob, and thanks for the warning.  Very important.

One of things pointed out a number of times about the hot water heater is that it need not run all the time.  It heats up in about 15 to 20 minutes and will give you hot water for a long time.

You are wise in just turning it on for that short time, maybe even right when you plug in before you start your A/C, and then turning it off and keeping it off until the hot water runs out (which would be a few good showers and lotsa clean dishes!).

You can do the math on the load:  1,500 watts for the heater, only you know the draw from your A/C, and the start, and restart as it cylces, load of the compressor is the most telling constituent of that load. 

I assume that you have also checked the wiring after your breaker failure.

The other thing to consider is the quality and condition of all of the connections behind the electrical panel's face, in addition to the breaker.  While I'm sure yours is clean as a baby's bottom, I have seen some that are like the other kind of the baby's bottom, and were just situations where the worst was about to happen.

Mom's still right, cleanliness does count.
Title: Re: Shore power voltage & Tripped Breaker w/ Hot Water & A/C
Post by: sdaly66 on May 30, 2007, 05:16:14 AM
Good advice, thanks.

Of course, I wouldn't know what it's like to have air conditioning.  LOL
Title: Re: Shore power voltage & Tripped Breaker w/ Hot Water & A/C
Post by: Mike Vaccaro on May 31, 2007, 09:03:16 AM
I'm a fan of monitoring both DC and AC systems with some type of multimeter.  We use a Link 10 for the DC system on our boat and a Blue Sea Systems AC multimeter for the AC side.  Neither one of these components are inexpensive; but they provide a great deal of flexibility for energy management.  We do have air conditioning on board, and as other posts have noted, you can't run all AC appliances simultaneously if the total amperage draw is greater than 30 amps (or the maximum amperage that the shore power circuit is capable of delivering, e.g., 15 or 20 amps).  It's also not a tremendous idea to run any circuit at 100% rated capacity for extended periods of time. 

With the ability to monitor actual system draw, you can make a rapid assessment about whether or not you need to turn off the coffee pot to run the vacuum.  The DC meter may also allow you to monitor the health of your battery and charging systems as well. 

The air conditioner is likely to be the highest drawing component installed, but depending on the unit, it may still be practical to run it on a 20 amp circuit.  Amperage draw will be highest when the compressor is first switched on, but then taper off rapidly.  On the old (circa early 90's) King Air unit we have on our boat, this amperage spike averages 10 amps.  With "background" AC draw (usually 1.3-2.0 amps) created by the battery charger powering DC systems, peak amperage will be around 24-25 when the compressor kicks in.  It will then rapidly drop to 13-14 amps as the motor stabilizes.  Depending on the configuration of the shore power circuit, this may or may not trip the circuit breaker--it shouldn't trip the breaker in your boat, but the breaker at the dock.  If the dock breaker does not trip, your system will run fine; but not if add much else to the load! 

With some models of air conditioner, there is a simple check you can perform if you want to be sure that your on-board system wiring is good: you can run the compressor unit without cooling water.  If the system is working normally, it will overheat fairly quickly and shut itself down by tripping the dedicated on-board air conditioning circuit breaker.  Check with the manufacturer before you try this, however, as 1) it may not work with all units; or 2) you may damage your air conditioner in the process.  By the way, you may encounter this exact set of circumstances if you attempt to run the air conditioner with the cooling sea-cock closed!     

Hot water heaters and coffee pots are also appliances that are relatively high-draw that cycle on and off regularly.  This will become very apparent if you monitor system amperage when you've got appliances on.  After a while, you will develop a good feel for energy requirements and become adept at turning components off and on to maximize efficiency and minimize problems.  Hence the reason many newer boats have multiple AC circuits and/or 50 amp service vs. 30!

Your nose is generally the best detector for the initial phase of an electrical malfunction that is a potential fire hazard, is is monitoring the physical temperature of a circuit breaker or wire (i.e., touch).  Any abnormal odor probably is (abnormal!) and should be investigated immediately.  If in doubt, de-power and carefully re-power one circuit at a time to avoid problems. 

In an emergency, beer can always be cooled by ice and the boat sails just fine without electricity or an engine!

Cheers,

Mike
Title: Re: Shore power voltage & Tripped Breaker w/ Hot Water & A/C
Post by: Jim Price on June 04, 2007, 09:30:40 AM
Bob K, another point on the hot water heater.  Don't know if you have ever replaced the heating element but your boat is older like mine and I replaced mine a couple of years ago (buy element from Home Depot) and it made a BIG difference in heating up.  If yours is original, it is probably covered with scale; thus you will use more "juice" to heat the water and bingo, there goes the breaker.    :thumb:
Title: Re: Shore power voltage & Tripped Breaker w/ Hot Water & A/C
Post by: Stu Jackson on June 04, 2007, 09:53:37 AM
Another trick on hot water heaters:  if you get in the habit of using the hot water faucet, even when there is no hot water, you'll keep gunk moving through the heater and perhaps reduce the amount of scale buildup on the coil; it also reduces any chance of rotten egg smells from the hot water side.