Catalina 34

General Activities => Main Message Board => Topic started by: Medved on October 06, 2021, 12:16:19 PM

Title: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Medved on October 06, 2021, 12:16:19 PM
Hi all, I have reached out to local vendor to install Raymarine i60 Wind Pack, with Short Arm Vane Transducer on my 1988 C34. Vendor asked for 2K to do the install. Does this sound reasonable? asking as a newbie
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Noah on October 06, 2021, 01:13:50 PM
Sorry but not enough info for me to evaluate. Deck step or keel step? Mast up or down? Replacing old instrument in same location? Wire run already? If new wire, will it be in conduit in the mast or loose? Lots of variables... also please put your year, hull number, engine type info in your signature. It will help us answer other questions going forward.
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Ron Hill on October 06, 2021, 02:37:58 PM
Med : Look in the old Mainsheet Tech notes and you find an article about installing a wind instrument on top of a keel stepped mast while the mast is up!!

A thought
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Kyle Ewing on October 06, 2021, 03:49:56 PM
Medved--Last summer I replaced my Datamarine instruments with an i70s wind/depth/speed pack.  It took me a couple of weekends (10-20 hours?) to remove old and install new, including running new wiring.  A rigger charged $200 to install the wind instrument only, mast up (I connected it).  I didn't have an existing wind instrument so he used the VHF coax to bring a messenger line up through the mast conduit and pull the wind cable down.  It took him and a helper an hour or less for the job.  He said it went as smoothly as it could.  My 1990 has a keel stepped mast.

I agree with Noah that there are a lot of variables to the cost, including hourly rate and bid type (hourly estimate or fixed bid).
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: LogoFreak on October 06, 2021, 08:56:39 PM
You can also go with the wireless wind instrument instead, no wires to run. I've had mine for many years and love it. $2000 in labour sounds a bit excessive to me to be honest, unless that included stepping down the mast and dealing with the rigging.
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Medved on October 07, 2021, 02:03:23 AM
Quote from: Kyle Ewing on October 06, 2021, 03:49:56 PM
Medved--Last summer I replaced my Datamarine instruments with an i70s wind/depth/speed pack.  It took me a couple of weekends (10-20 hours?) to remove old and install new, including running new wiring.  A rigger charged $200 to install the wind instrument only, mast up (I connected it).  I didn't have an existing wind instrument so he used the VHF coax to bring a messenger line up through the mast conduit and pull the wind cable down.  It took him and a helper an hour or less for the job.  He said it went as smoothly as it could.  My 1990 has a keel stepped mast.

I agree with Noah that there are a lot of variables to the cost, including hourly rate and bid type (hourly estimate or fixed bid).

My apologies for not providing all the info up front, but it is a tall rig with a keel step and no previous wind instrument and the mast is up/boat in the water. What this vendor described to me, is exactly what Kyle did using VHF cable to bring a messenger. I reached out to a rigger to see what they would charge to do this.
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: ewengstrom on October 08, 2021, 11:52:01 AM
Logo, I've heard mixed reviews about the wireless units, but yours is a good endorsement. Might I inquire as to who's instruments you currently have installed? I've got a relatively new B&G GPS and this thing is just great to work with. Since I don't have any wind instrument currently installed I'd given thought to the B&G wireless unit.
Just interested in who's unit your using sir.
Thanks!!!!
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Ron Hill on October 08, 2021, 02:15:09 PM
Med : I Like I said : look at my article!!!
I did it with myself with someone that went up the mast.  Took us about 1-2 hrs to get the wind instrument mounted as we were doing it and inventing the "how to" at the same time.  Look at the article - it might save you a few boat bucks!??!   :shock:

A thought
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Ron Hill on October 08, 2021, 02:17:09 PM
Med : That wind instrument installation is still working 30+ years later!!!

A thought
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Medved on October 09, 2021, 03:05:46 AM
@Ron I tried to search for it, but could not find it. Can you post a link?
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: LogoFreak on October 09, 2021, 08:25:21 AM
Quote from: ewengstrom on October 08, 2021, 11:52:01 AM
Logo, I've heard mixed reviews about the wireless units, but yours is a good endorsement. Might I inquire as to who's instruments you currently have installed? I've got a relatively new B&G GPS and this thing is just great to work with. Since I don't have any wind instrument currently installed I'd given thought to the B&G wireless unit.
Just interested in who's unit your using sir.
Thanks!!!!

Hey Eric, my entire electronics package is from Raymarine. I find their customer service and tech support great and they stand behind their product. My wind instrument is their micro talk package that links what would be the tactic line with my stng network (nmea 2000). It's the T120 masthead trasnducer, a T113 handheld display and the micro talk gateway that plugs into the STng network.

I really didn't want to have one more cable going up the mast as the conduit is only a 1" pvc tube, I had the mast down so it wasn't because running the wire would be a pita.
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Ron Hill on October 09, 2021, 01:48:45 PM
Med : That was the August 1995 Vol 13 #3

Never thought of using the radio wire as a tracer (then pulling a new radio wire and the wind wire together) because my radio wire came out the side, but that might be a thought - rather than coming out the top like I did. 

A thought
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Noah on October 09, 2021, 04:00:29 PM
My VHF comes out of the side as well. The black wire ties were sticking up left there on purpose to discourage birds. So far (six year later) seems to still work. I also installed a second PVC conduit in the mast that only goes up to the spreaders. It carries my radar wiring and spreader lights.
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: WTunnessen on October 12, 2021, 03:15:41 PM
RE:  Wireless - About ten years ago I installed the Raymarine wireless wind & depth-speed package because it was a cost and time effective upgrade. Also liked avoiding running wires.  My experience with the wind instrument has been mixed. Sometimes it works great and other times the wind direction is off about 10-30 degrees. While it can be re-calibrated at the instrument easily, its still annoying and I ALWAYS check the ole wind vane for accuracy. Never had an issue with the solar cell. Depth and speed work fine. Mine is not networked with an autopilot or GPS. Been meaning to call/write customer service to see if there something else that can be done about the wind direction since I can't find much on the web about the issue. Haven't got around to it since mostly I watch the sail tell-tales. 8)
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Jim Hardesty on October 13, 2021, 03:18:11 AM
QuoteSometimes it works great and other times the wind direction is off about 10-30 degrees.

WT,  Before you blame the wireless feature, consider other factors.  Sometimes, especially when the wind aft and the main is way out or the spinnaker is up, my wired raymarine often reads off.  I look at the mast head and the windex, aft on mast, is pointing one way, the wind vane is pointing another, forward on mast.  I think it's due to the short arm.  Raymarine does have a higher and longer wind instrument arm mostly used on racers.
Jim
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Gary Brockman on October 13, 2021, 12:01:50 PM
I have had Tacktick instruments on Squall for about eight years and have been very happy with the information they provide, particularly true wind speed and true wind angle to the boat. My only complaint has been that on two occasions the wind data became intermittent and sometimes not at all. Raymarine said that although my tall rig was around the effective limit for the wireless masthead unit, the problem was likely in the sender. Each time I sent the masthead unit to Raymarine for repair, which was free the first time and $150 the second time. There have been no problems for the last four years.
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: KeelsonGraham on October 14, 2021, 02:16:11 AM
Quote from: Medved on October 06, 2021, 12:16:19 PM
Hi all, I have reached out to local vendor to install Raymarine i60 Wind Pack, with Short Arm Vane Transducer on my 1988 C34. Vendor asked for 2K to do the install. Does this sound reasonable? asking as a newbie

Hi Medved. I've just installed a new Raymarine wind instrument. My riggers charged me about $200 to fit the masthead unit. I did the rest myself even though I'm new to boat ownership.

Running the wiring involves a bit of boat yoga and some patience mousing the cable up through the Edson guard rail. You'll need a large hole saw and powerful mains powered drill to make the hole for the instrument. None of it is difficult. $2k bucks seems way over the top.

MaineSail has written a good piece about how to drill holes in NavPods. I followed his advice exactly and it worked out just fine.
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: WTunnessen on October 14, 2021, 11:34:49 AM
Jim- Thanks for your thoughts on the wireless. Unfortunately, I've noticed the problem when both the windex and wireless sender are pointing in the same direction. It's also pretty clear that something is up when I'm close hauled and it's telling me the wind is on a beam reach.  What I need to do is contact Raymarine and get the sender serviced!
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: Medved on October 25, 2021, 04:30:12 AM
Quote from: KeelsonGraham on October 14, 2021, 02:16:11 AM
Quote from: Medved on October 06, 2021, 12:16:19 PM
Hi all, I have reached out to local vendor to install Raymarine i60 Wind Pack, with Short Arm Vane Transducer on my 1988 C34. Vendor asked for 2K to do the install. Does this sound reasonable? asking as a newbie

Hi Medved. I've just installed a new Raymarine wind instrument. My riggers charged me about $200 to fit the masthead unit. I did the rest myself even though I'm new to boat ownership.

Running the wiring involves a bit of boat yoga and some patience mousing the cable up through the Edson guard rail. You'll need a large hole saw and powerful mains powered drill to make the hole for the instrument. None of it is difficult. $2k bucks seems way over the top.

MaineSail has written a good piece about how to drill holes in NavPods. I followed his advice exactly and it worked out just fine.

I had rigger install the wind vane transducer and run the cable through the mast last week for few hundred based on suggestions here, so I don't know how that other vendor got to 2K. I am now trying to figure out how to run the cable to the instruments. Any further details or pictures from your install would be greatly appreciated.
Title: Re: Installing Raymarine wind instruments
Post by: KeelsonGraham on October 25, 2021, 06:17:54 AM
.
[/quote]

I had rigger install the wind vane transducer and run the cable through the mast last week for few hundred based on suggestions here, so I don't know how that other vendor got to 2K. I am now trying to figure out how to run the cable to the instruments. Any further details or pictures from your install would be greatly appreciated.
[/quote]

For SeatalkNG you need a special adapter called an ITC-5 (essentially an analog to digital converter). This has bayonet connectors to allow you to connect the 4 or so wires running from the wind vane. The ITC-5 also has plug-in sockets so that you can then connect it to the backbone. I'm guessing that there is an equivalent type of unit for Seatalk?