Catalina 34

General Activities => Main Message Board => Topic started by: Brad Young on November 14, 2012, 10:19:52 AM

Title: Jib Sheet XLS Yatch braid vs XLS extra T
Post by: Brad Young on November 14, 2012, 10:19:52 AM
I received some LXS Yatch braid (7/16) pretty cheap. Do you think this will work in place of the LXS extra T (7/16).
I plan on using it for my jib sheet.

Name           Tensile   Strands     Elastic Elongation
LXS Yatch      5,800       16         1.5% / 2.2 % / 2.9 %
LXS Extra T    6,100       25         0.5% / 0.8 % / 1 %

The stretch seems like a lot. With a 50ft sheet with a 30% load it  could stretch about 1.5 ft vs. 0.5ft
Seeing that I already have the Yatch Braid, would you use it or just get the Extra T.

Thanks
brad

Title: Re: Jib Sheet LXS Yatch braid vs LXS extra T
Post by: mainesail on November 14, 2012, 11:22:08 AM
Are you racing? With jib sheets stretch matters less as you just take a turn on the winch. I am adjusting my genny so often that line stretch matters les than it does for a halyard which is hard to adjust under load.

Do you mean XLS by Samson?
Title: Re: Jib Sheet LXS Yatch braid vs LXS extra T
Post by: Jim Hardesty on November 14, 2012, 11:36:59 AM
The stretch would only apply to the loaded section.  Depending on how you lead your sheets and genoa size this would be a lot less than 50 feet (may be 10 feet).  And the sheet loads are not high, sheets size has as much to do with hand feel as strength.  If it feels good use it.
Title: Re: Jib Sheet XLS Yatch braid vs XLS extra T
Post by: Brad Young on November 14, 2012, 01:39:18 PM

I did mean XLS.

If I race it is only for fun.

Very good point about the length of the sheet. 10ft vs 50ft

Thanks
brad
Title: Re: Jib Sheet LXS Yatch braid vs LXS extra T
Post by: Ron Hill on November 14, 2012, 03:00:36 PM
Brad : Both Jim and Main make very good points.

Here's mine - I recommend that you go for 1/2" genoa sheet lines.  They stay put in the self tailing #46 winches MUCH better than 7/16". 
I'm pleased with the Polyester Single Braid in 1/2" size.

A thought