I have twice removed my compass to tighten the hex bolt which provides tension on the throttle shaft. This of course means removing my electronics pod to be able to remove the compass...
Last month, I made sure to add some loctite to the threads thinking that the bolt had backed off the first time.
After only a month, the throttle will not hold it's position.
Has anyone else had this problem?
Thanks, Dave
Dave : No too sure that I would have used Locktite!!
You might go down to the engine, extend the inner wire on the throttle cable. Then clean any grease with lacquer thinner and spray some Belt Grip on the wire and see if that doesn't help.
Otherwise you might have to remove the compass again and remove, inspect and maybe replace that tightening bolt. If the female threads are stripped - then it'll mean re-tapping for a larger bolt!!
A few thoughts
Hi, a few of us have had the same problem. A small bungee around the throttle level is the lazybones fix.
I have the same problem, at max throttle it will back down to about 2000rpm. I just use tape to lock it in position.
Quote from: Ron Hill on August 11, 2018, 10:35:36 AM
Dave : No too sure that I would have used Locktite!!
You might go down to the engine, extend the inner wire on the throttle cable. Then clean any grease with lacquer thinner and spray some Belt Grip on the wire and see if that doesn't help.
Otherwise you might have to remove the compass again and remove, inspect and maybe replace that tightening bolt. If the female threads are stripped - then it'll mean re-tapping for a larger bolt!!
A few thoughts
Ron, I believe this is a problem on the throttle lever end at the pedestal and not the engine end.
I tighten the hex bolt and all is fine. A month later it starts slipping hence my thought that the bolt was backing out. No problem with any stripped threads.
I wonder if some kind of a rubber insert between the bolt and throttle rod might work better than metal to metal?
Dave : Put a slippage mark on that bolt and see if the bolt is turning. Which I don't think it is.
A thought
Mine does the same thing, it'll run all day at 2000 but I have to hold it or use the bungee trick to keep it up. Having said that, 2/3 - 3/4 should be the max you run that for extended time.
Your boat, your choice.
Had a similar problem on a 2001 MK II, I couldn't go higher that 1600 RPM. I called a mechanic and he suggested a cable brake. Installed it near the engine side and it seems to work. The part is from Seastar Solutions pt# 044386. Amazon carries them.
I don't like the idea of crushing the cable insulator but it does work.
https://groups.io/g/catalina30/message/100559
Great Picture Ken! - I know it well.
The question is why, after tightening the machine screw, does the throttle start to slip, even after using a thread lock to keep the machine screw from backing out?
I contacted Edson on Monday but have not had a response :-(
The idea wasn't the pic, it was to check the thread. Besides the 4 foot difference, one of the two groups will figure it out. :-)
Dave,
I had the same problem on my C36. I talked with Edson, and they said I should try putting a cable clamp (also called a wire clamp or a saddle clamp) on the throttle cable, near the engine. Much easier to access, install, and adjust. I can't remember the exact size. Available at most hardware stores. Hope this helps.
https://webriggingsupply.com/product/516-malleable-wire-rope-clip/?gclid=CjwKCAjw8O7bBRB0EiwAfbrThx3yCV2-FDPFIVgCwpJZr2YRm_wUe8VnJIeiEru5YCDu_u_Ndga8axoC42oQAvD_BwE
Quote from: Tom Soko on August 21, 2018, 10:04:12 AM
Dave,
I had the same problem on my C36. I talked with Edson, and they said I should try putting a cable clamp (also called a wire clamp or a saddle clamp) on the throttle cable, near the engine. Much easier to access, install, and adjust. I can't remember the exact size. Available at most hardware stores. Hope this helps.
https://webriggingsupply.com/product/516-malleable-wire-rope-clip/?gclid=CjwKCAjw8O7bBRB0EiwAfbrThx3yCV2-FDPFIVgCwpJZr2YRm_wUe8VnJIeiEru5YCDu_u_Ndga8axoC42oQAvD_BwE
Thanks Tom!
Am I correct that the clamp is used to crimp the casing onto the actual cable to increase the friction?
Has there been any abrasion to the cable as a result and how long have you had it in place?
Dave
Horror Freight has stainless, 1/8" wire rope clamps that should work nicely?
You could experiment by lightly clamping a vice grip (tm) on the cable, then greater tension, just to see if that corrects it.
-k
Dave,
Yes, that is correct. You tighten the clamp around the wire sheath just enough to create more friction between the inside wire and the sheath. It might take a few 1/8th turns to get it just right. I had that setup on my C36 for probably 12-14 of the 18 years I owned it, and there were no problems. I think it was actually Will Keene, owner of Edson, who suggested that fix for the slipping throttle. Also, no need to spend the extra $$ for SS clamps. Any hardware store variety will do. There's really no exposure to salt water in that spot on the engine.
Quote from: Tom Soko on August 22, 2018, 08:19:26 PM
Dave,
Yes, that is correct. You tighten the clamp around the wire sheath just enough to create more friction between the inside wire and the sheath. It might take a few 1/8th turns to get it just right. I had that setup on my C36 for probably 12-14 of the 18 years I owned it, and there were no problems. I think it was actually Will Keene, owner of Edson, who suggested that fix for the slipping throttle. Also, no need to spend the extra $$ for SS clamps. Any hardware store variety will do. There's really no exposure to salt water in that spot on the engine.
Thanks! Being an avid bicyclist, that is just so contrary :)
Looks like we all have had this issue. Years ago I put on a cable clamp,as suggested, a slight tighten, and it has solved the throttle slip ever since. Cheap, easy fix, just don't over tighten the nuts.
Hi all,
Any updates to this fix? I have the slipping throttle issue and don't want to make a safety issue but I guess if done gently....
I used this fix on my last boat with a Edson pedestal that did not have the adjustment bolt on the throttle. The only solution was the rope trick or using the cable clamp, I went with the clamp and never had any issues. Seems too "simple" to actually work...but it does.
I have the same problem. Use a velcro strap. This winter I ordered a package of new ones from Amazon. They are "Reusable Cinch Straps" with the logo of of Envisioned. Work great. For my boat they need to be 10'' long.
Paul
Just make sure you're not (or anyone else has been) lubricating the Delron bushing that the throttle handle goes through into the pedestal. This bushing can be replaced if it's been contaminated by lubricant. I think I had used all of the other suggestions too, tape, clamp, bungee.
Craig
Quote
using the cable clamp, I went with the clamp and never had any issues. Seems too "simple" to actually work...but it does.
Don't overthink this - a little tension, you don't need to try to crush the assembly to death.
Harbor Freight carries the low-cost wire rope clips (in stainless!) Twofer 2.99.
https://www.harborfreight.com/2-piece-1-4-quarter-inch-wire-rope-clips-93891.html
Easier to adjust if need be than disassembling the binnacle.
Thanks. Is 1/4" best sizing? I saw someone else mention 1/8" somewhere earlier in this thread. It'll just save me time as I haven't looked at the throttle cable yet...
I doubt 1/8" would fit the cable sheath. It's probably more like 3/16" OD, so the 1/4" should work nicely.
I've been following this thread, want to add my 2 cents, yes I've had to use rubber bands for a temporary fix. I keep some on board. But I don't find removing the compass and using the adjusting bolt to be all that much work and by then it's time to lube the bearings and chain. It usually lasts a couple of seasons or more. As a former motorcycle guy, just don't like the idea of crushing a cable, even a little.
I wouldn't criticize anyone for using the clamp. Your boat your choice. I only want to suggest, try the adjustment as designed first.
Jim
Thanks all.
Hi Jim,
I'm also a biker/ auto racer, etc. and agree with your thoughts but, at these rpm's, a little less concerned than turning 6,000+ :shock:
I'll try the proper fix but suspect the clamp may be a reasonable mod.
Cheers.
I ended up using a cable clamp. Cheap, easy, perfect.
Quote from: DaveBMusik on March 30, 2020, 05:31:08 PM
I ended up using a cable clamp. Cheap, easy, perfect.
Yes, worked for me as well. :clap